Abuse Report
1 .  Thread's URL
2 .  Comment
3 .  Your Name
4 .  E-mail
    




User Name   Password
This is a support forum for those who have left
or are in the process of leaving fundamentalist Christianity

Current Forum Since June 2001


Views:257     

<<Previous ThreadNext Thread>>
Page 1 of 1    
Author Comment
MissUnknown
| Move to Bottom
 
Author



Rank:none
Status:
Score: 0
Posts: 4
From:
Registered: 03/12/2008
Time spent: 0 hours

(Date Posted:03/12/2008 16:46:16)

Would you still have served Christ without the fear of Hell?

How many of you would still take Christianity as seriously and have given your lives to it, if there was no hell?


Yes, I would have served Him whole heartedly and given my life to Him.
No, Hell is what made me convert to Christianity in the first place.
I might have started in the faith, but in time the cares of this life would have taken more concern then following a religion without consequence.
     
snakechic
| Move to Top | Move to Bottom
 
1#



Rank:none
Status:
Score:0
Posts:3489
From:
Registered: 11/02/2004
Time spent: 1846 hours

RE:Would you still have served Christ without the fear of Hell?
(Date Posted:03/12/2008 18:08:46)


I don't believe in 'hell' or anything that is so obviously concocted by people to serve as a 'stick' or to enforce their own judgements of  'other' people deserving such a punishment.

I don't think your choice of answers is very open to the idea that 'hell' is simply a mythological idea stolen by christians from earlier times. It has pagan roots.
Also the idea of   'hell' is very dependent on which denomination of christianity you belong to - they all differ so as a concept its very loose. In your question you seem to suggest that 'hell' is a 'reality' and somehow necessary to christianity/religion?

Which denomination are you MissK?

(Message edited by snakechic on 03/12/2008 18:21:27)

--------------------------------------------------------------
In exchange for obedience, Christianity promises salvation in an afterlife; but in order to elicit obedience through this promise, Christianity must convince people that they need salvation, that there is something to be saved from. Christianity has nothing to offer a happy person living in a natural, intelligible universe. If Christianity is to gain a motivational foothold, it must declare war on earthly pleasure and happiness, and this, historically, has been its precise course of action. In the eyes of Christianity, woman(man) is sinful and helpless in the face of God, and is potential fuel for the flames of hell. Just as Christianity must destroy reason before it can introduce faith, so it must destroy happiness before it can introduce salvation.

-- George H Smith, Atheism: The Case Against God

snakechic
| Move to Top | Move to Bottom
 
2#



Rank:none
Status:
Score:0
Posts:3489
From:
Registered: 11/02/2004
Time spent: 1846 hours

RE:Would you still have served Christ without the fear of Hell?
(Date Posted:03/12/2008 18:22:57)

There have been heaps of discussion on the topic..here's one of my favorite post to date....

You know something? I am fucking sick and tired of Christians using "hell" as their favorite cattle prod to scare people into buying their "Pascal's Wager-ism". I am tired of Christians claiming that the reason they witness to the "lost", and the reason that they post on this forum, is to "warn" people about "hell." Fuck, I'm tired of Christians just mentioning the word "hell"! And why? Because Christians don't even believe in this "Hell" they promote. They don't! Not one, fucking word.

Bold statement, but can I back it up?

You better fucking well believe I can. Start reading.

<!--quoteo-->
QUOTE


<!--quotec-->
"You are really convinced that you've got all the answers. You've really got yourself tricked into believing that you're 100% right. Well, let me tell you just one thing. Do you consider yourself to be compassionate of other humans? If you're right, as you say you are, and you believe that [sinners burn in hell for eternity for simply rejecting Jesus], then how can you sleep at night? When you speak with me, you are speaking with someone who you believe is walking directly into eternal damnation, into an endless onslaught of horrendous pain which your 'loving' god created, yet you stand by and do nothing.

If you believed one bit that thousands every day were falling into an eternal and unchangeable [and horrendous] fate, you should be running the streets mad with rage at their blindness. That's equivalent to standing on a street corner and watching every person that passes you walk blindly directly into the path of a bus and die, yet you stand idly by and do nothing. You're just twiddling your thumbs, happy in the knowledge that one day that 'walk' signal will shine your way across the road.

Think about it. Imagine the horrors Hell must have in store if the Bible is true. You're just going to allow that to happen and not care about saving anyone but yourself? If you're right then you're an uncaring, unemotional and purely selfish (expletive) that has no right to talk about subjects such as love and caring."

This is an excerpt from an e-mail sent to Evangelist Ray Comfort of Living Waters. [This e-mail can be found at
http://www.repentamerica.com/letterfromateist.html]

Words [in brackets] are my addition.
<!--QuoteEnd-->
<!--QuoteEEnd-->
And then there are these damning words from The Man himself, Robert Ingersoll:

<!--quoteo-->
QUOTE

<!--quotec-->"If there is a God who will damn his children forever, I would rather go to hell than to go to heaven and keep the society of such an infamous tyrant. I make my choice now. I despise that doctrine. It has covered the cheeks of this world with tears. It has polluted the hearts of children, and poisoned the imaginations of men. It has been a constant pain, a perpetual terror to every good man and woman and child. It has filled the good with horror and with fear; but it has had no effect upon the infamous and base. It has wrung the hearts of the tender, it has furrowed the cheeks of the good. This doctrine never should be preached again. What right have you, sir, Mr. clergyman, you, minister of the gospel to stand at the portals of the tomb, at the vestibule of eternity, and fill the future with horror and with fear? I do not believe this doctrine, neither do you. If you did, you could not sleep one moment. Any man who believes it, and has within his breast a decent, throbbing heart, will go insane. A man who believes that doctrine and does not go insane has the heart of a snake and the conscience of a hyena."
..........Robert Ingersoll, "The Liberty of Man, Woman and Child", 1877<!--QuoteEnd-->

<!--QuoteEEnd-->

Next, years ago I, the Grinch, read a story related by minister Chuck Swindoll, I believe it was in the pages of his book The Grace Awakening. (Or was it in Simple Faith? Well, either way, Swindoll wrote it. Who knows whether or not this is a True tale of woe? We all know how much Christians enjoy creating tales of inspiration to motivate their followers.)

He re-tells the story of a felon convicted of murder and who was on death row in prison. On the day of his execution, the priest visited the felon to administer Last Rites. On the way to the execution chamber, the priest dispassionately and lazily spoke of sin, forgiveness and the fires of eternal damnation. The condemned prisoner became quite offended at the priest's cavalier attitude and took umbrage with him. He was angry that the priest seemed to care so little for such a horrible fate that allegedly awaited the condemned.

The criminal upbraided the priest sharply saying that if he, the criminal, believed in such a horrible destination as hell awaited mankind, then he would not sleep for proclaiming a warning. The criminal said that were it him who claimed to believe such a thing as hell, then he would cross miles of broken glass on his hands and knees to deliver this message and warn the lost away from this doom!

And then finally, we have the sundry posts and dodges from the assorted Christians we've gotten on this very forum. Not fucking ONE of them believes in a REAL, LITERAL HELL! Not one. They ALL have their OWN, PERSONAL and LESS OFFENSIVE IDEA of "hell". ("Separation from god", "loneliness", or a "burning thirst", as Billy Graham calls it.) Something that they can live with and still believe themselves to be decent human beings.

They offer analogies about "warning people about to go over waterfalls", and "saving someone from a burning building", however THOSE analogies fall flat on their faces. Whereas the "fire" and "waterfall" are REAL and can be verified as a legitimate THREAT to life and limb, the Christian notion of "hell" is a mere fabrication. Verified by the fact that Christian efforts to "save" anyone from this "danger" is so fucking cavalier! When is the last time anyone saw a casual fire fighter or lifeguard, just TALKING about saving a life in peril? Or do they get busy and dive headlong into danger?

So THIS is why I say that Christians themselves, (no matter WHAT they profess in their catechisms, or statements of faith, or Apostle's Creeds) DO NOT believe in the doctrine of Hell! They don't believe a word of it. The very idea of the Bible Hell that JESUS preached is offensive, disturbing and monstrous. And the idea that a "loving God" could eternally damn humanity to this fate is anathema to Christians. They recoil at this accusation against their god. And with good reason.

How could anyone, who believes in Eternal TORMENT for family, friends, neighbors and even strangers, possibly sleep knowing this horror awaits them? And how could you worship the "God" that created "hell"? Anyone who ACTUALLY believed in a "lake of burning fire", where family and friends go to be punished for eternity, would not stop to sleep or eat. They would be incensed and mad with fasting, prayer and preaching warnings to the lost. AT ANY COST TO THEMSELVES!

They'd NEVER stop warning people. They wouldn't be wasting time working for a paycheck. Got more important work to do! It's sack cloth and ashes time! They wouldn't be sitting at home eating a sumptuous meal and watching "Must See TV", while thousands each MINUTE died and were being sent to Hell! They wouldn't take vacations, and instead they'd be on street corners, in malls and in market places wailing in lament for the lost souls around and about them. They wouldn't be wasting time arguing fruitlessly the finer points of church doctrine with APOSTATES on internet forums, who have already rejected the message. (Hello all!) They'd be pestering neighbors, family and friends morning, noon, and night, not caring if they believed them to be mad. They'd suffer every indignity, every beating, every sling and arrow, every depravation of the body and mind, every humiliating treatment of their person including imprisonment or institutionalization, all for the opportunity to warn the lost of the perils of Hell Fire!

And they'd "count it all joy", as did the "Apostle Paul."

But note for the record that NO CHRISTIAN IS DOING THIS! NOT ONE.

Oh sure, we've got the Sunday Morning sermons, delivered to PEW SITTERS who have already heard the message. There are even your "weekend warrior" Christians who make momentary nuisances of themselves in parks and on street corners as they get into fights with on-lookers and the cops. Even PAID evangelists and missionaries who go forth and "preach the gospel".

But what REALLY are they preaching? (IF they preach at all.) A gospel of feel-goodism and good works and faithful tithing/obedience to the church. Or they spew vitriol and venom delivered against homosexuals and atheists, because "God Hates Sinners!" Christians typically content themselves with passing out a few Bibles, pamphlets, maybe a hot meal or two, some clothes and some pithy catch-phrases designed to help one (intimidate one) to live a "better life for Christ". Thus making our society a better, safer "Christian" nation.

But...where is the PANIC and URGENCY of these stalwart evangelists as they warn about the fires of Hell?

It's not there. And why not? Because THEY don't believe in Hell (i.e. the "Lake of Burning Fire") anymore than I do. Why panic and warn about something that you KNOW doesn't exist? Why waste time wearing yourself to the bone about some penalty that you KNOW is not there, when there is living to be done here on Earth?

Much better to run the church like the business enterprise that it is. Build bigger church buildings, and sell Christian products to other gullible Christians, to stimulate the Christian economy. Gotta make sure all the Christian artistes receive their "Dove Awards" and the recognition for being the Top Christian Act of the Year. Then there is the important work of petitioning Congress to get prayer and the Ten Commandments back in schools, so Christian "values" can be taught to the chillin' of America. And for God's sake let's make sure that homosexuals don't ruin the institution of marriage! When Christ returns we sure as fuck don't want him seeing THAT perversity of Adam and Steve kissing!

CHRISTIANS DON'T BELIEVE IN HELL! If they did they'd be frantically warning against it and not be wasting time with anything else.

And since I'm on a roll, let me say that Christians don't "believe" in anything they say. For IF they did, the entire WORLD would see a marked difference in the way they behave and live. THIS WORLD and all that it offers would hold NO interest. They'd sell all they have, give it to the poor, go into the world and preach. But they don't do ANY of this. And why not?

Christians are "storing up treasures here on earth" as fast as these treasures can be created. They live in and enjoy this world. Christians are even AFRAID to leave this world! Watch as the Christians pray against sickness, disease, accidental injury, LOSS OF PROPERTY and POSITION, and even against DEATH. Despite all of their vainglorious boastings of being "blessed children of God", and "looking forward to meeting Him face-to-face", Christians LOVE this world. They cling tenaciously to it, and they are TERRIFIED of dying. Terrified of LOSING something precious...their LIFE in THIS world.

The ONLY Christians who live in poverty are the ones who are FORCED into it by their circumstances. You will NEVER see any of today's affluent church-goers sell all of their possessions and take up the life of poor, spirit-filled believers, suffering for the "cross of Christ." Warning the "lost and dying" about "Judgment Day." Not gonna happen.

But...why should any of this be? Why this marked discrepancy between what Christians SAY and what they DO? Between what the Bible teaches and what Christians "believe"? Most assuredly it's because they don't believe the horse shit they're shoveling either! Because they don't believe a fucking WORD of it. Not one word. They just like to pretend that they do. It makes them look good when they're puffing themselves up in church circles. Why actually LIVE, sacrifice and DIE for "Christ", when you can just TALK about doing it? Or better yet, just talk about some OTHER Christians who allegedly did it somewhere else, at some other time. "What an inspiration St. Paul or Justin Martyr are! Aren't THEY grand examples of faith-filled men?"

Right...and just what have YOU done for Christ lately? Besides wasting time debating unbelievers on Ex-Christian.Net, that is.

"Who would die for a lie?" HAH! The better question is, "Who would LIVE for a lie?" Apparently not too fucking many.


<!--coloro:#33CC00--><!--/coloro-->"If a man would follow, today, the teachings of the Old Testament, he would be a criminal. If he would follow strictly the teachings of the New, he would be insane.".....Robert Ingersoll
<!--colorc-->
<!--/colorc-->

http://www.ex-christian.net/index.php?showtopic=10491


--------------------------------------------------------------
In exchange for obedience, Christianity promises salvation in an afterlife; but in order to elicit obedience through this promise, Christianity must convince people that they need salvation, that there is something to be saved from. Christianity has nothing to offer a happy person living in a natural, intelligible universe. If Christianity is to gain a motivational foothold, it must declare war on earthly pleasure and happiness, and this, historically, has been its precise course of action. In the eyes of Christianity, woman(man) is sinful and helpless in the face of God, and is potential fuel for the flames of hell. Just as Christianity must destroy reason before it can introduce faith, so it must destroy happiness before it can introduce salvation.

-- George H Smith, Atheism: The Case Against God

MissUnknown
| Move to Top | Move to Bottom
 
3#



Status:
From:
Registered: 03/12/2008
Time spent: 0 hours

RE:Would you still have served Christ without the fear of Hell?
(Date Posted:03/12/2008 18:30:29)

snakechic,
I don't consider myself a denomination. I'm not even sure if I consider myself a Christian atleast not what I believe a Christian is. I know that as I said in my other post that I did live a Christian life and take it very seriously. I have pretty much been back and forth with things as I work it out in my head as I am sure many others have as well.  As for your comment that I was not being very open as to what hell was , well that is because I wanted to know basically what fundamentalist type christians thought about serving Christ with or without punishment. That is because if you believe it is some mythological place then you won't be serving Christ out of fear which is why I asked the question in the first place. I have wondered many times how many people hold strongly to their faith because of the fear of divine retribution. I have wanted to ask Christians this and ex- christians. I guess when I say Christians I am saying people that believe in Jesus Christ as the only way to heaven and that hell is a literal place.
I am not excluding others as Christians. I guess I should have worded it differently. Basically if you are a Christian that believes in Hell as a literal place and that Christ is the only way to heaven, how did that effect the way you served Christ and the length of time you served.

Ah well, it was my first poll and I'm new to all of this.
snakechic
| Move to Top | Move to Bottom
 
4#



Rank:none
Status:
Score:0
Posts:3489
From:
Registered: 11/02/2004
Time spent: 1846 hours

RE:Would you still have served Christ without the fear of Hell?
(Date Posted:03/12/2008 18:46:59)

Reply to MissUnknown (03/12/2008 2:46 PM).
snakechic,
I don't consider myself a denomination.Ah well, it was my first poll and I'm new to all of this.

About the denom thing...that was simply to acknowledge that different denoms have many and various views of 'hell'........even 'fundamentalism'  - it is not a united bunch at all. There are SDAist, JW, Mormons, Penties, etc etc..etc...as well as all the other types of religion that hold some idea of 'hell'...ie. BUddhist, Islam etc.

I was wondering where you are coming from?
I'm glad you are asking questions - I'd have to agree that the concept of 'hell' is certainly one of the 'fears' that keep people peddling around in a circle..............but for me personally even  as a child I found it repulsive and made me reject people who spread that fear around.

Nice poll...very tricked up. I like it...just wasn't sure about your 'narrow' choices - left no wriggle room - thanks for clarifying.

Btw...I think its great to make fun and ridicle the concept - reason I posted that old post.

P.s. What did you think of that 'quote' post I pasted in this thread. A lot of people have read it and thought it was worth a read.

(Message edited by snakechic on 03/12/2008 18:53:58)

--------------------------------------------------------------
In exchange for obedience, Christianity promises salvation in an afterlife; but in order to elicit obedience through this promise, Christianity must convince people that they need salvation, that there is something to be saved from. Christianity has nothing to offer a happy person living in a natural, intelligible universe. If Christianity is to gain a motivational foothold, it must declare war on earthly pleasure and happiness, and this, historically, has been its precise course of action. In the eyes of Christianity, woman(man) is sinful and helpless in the face of God, and is potential fuel for the flames of hell. Just as Christianity must destroy reason before it can introduce faith, so it must destroy happiness before it can introduce salvation.

-- George H Smith, Atheism: The Case Against God

MissUnknown
| Move to Top | Move to Bottom
 
5#



Status:
From:
Registered: 03/12/2008
Time spent: 0 hours

RE:Would you still have served Christ without the fear of Hell?
(Date Posted:03/12/2008 20:16:05)

  • P.s. What did you think of that 'quote' post I pasted in this thread. A lot of people have read it and thought it was worth a read.
Hi again,
I was actually in the middle of replying to you when my computer shut off. Basically what I said is that I have felt a lot of what that person posted.
I have felt disgust with Christianity's God. I have also at the same time as you mentioned in another post used the same God as a crutch I guess.
I am in pretty bad health right now and it was always comforting for me to turn and pray and have that hope that if I just had enough faith that maybe I would be healed. To be honest this Christianity thing for me has been kind of a schizo experience.

The thing that person posted about if you were a christian and truly believed in hell you would walk over broken glass to warn others is somewhat true. I took a lot of things I read literally when I first started my conversion. I literally almost ended up in a mental institution over it. I don't know if that is my problem (I'm not crazy but maybe I took things too literally) or that the bible really is that hard of a thing to live up to. I freaked out so bad at the thought of people burning in hell that I started warning and witnessing door to door and I looked like a religious freak to most people. There is a lot more to the story but it's long and I don't have the patience to write it all down now. I do know that there are many out there risking their lives to witness to others and giving up most or if not all of what they have to serve Christ and I know that there are many more who don't.  For me that is not something I concern myself with most of the time of who's doing what.  Don't get me wrong it can be a disgusting thing to see what some so called christians do but my thoughts have always been there will always be those that abuse power or fake something for their own ends I can't be concerned with that to the point that it keeps me from seeking truth.

The problem with that article is that they lump all christians in the same boat. Just because the majority of Christians past or present have been deceitful or caused wars or whatever it is that they have done doesn't make all christians evil. It's the same as accusing all whites of slavery and all men of being sexist and the reason women have been treated second class for centuries. A lot of men through out history surpressed women's right to vote, to have an education, etc... that doesn't mean there weren't those few out there that stood for equality and knew what it was to do their  best and treat others with equal respect.  I'm not saying I'm not disgusted with a lot of Christianity the more I learn I'm just saying I'm not about to lump everyone in the same boat.
logophile
| Move to Top | Move to Bottom
 
6#



Rank:none
Status:
Score:0
Posts:93
From:
Registered: 08/15/2005
Time spent: 0 hours

RE:Would you still have served Christ without the fear of Hell?
(Date Posted:03/13/2008 17:23:50)

I converted out of fear of hell, but the "hell" I speak of was the hell I'd catch at home if I didn't do what was expected of me. That's not to say I didn't at any point beleive there could have been a hell, I'm just saying that the punishment I already knew and had experienced was a much stronger motivator.

About  that quote on snakechics post from the person who said that nobody really believes in hell.  ..... It does make some sense that ideally, anybody who beleived there was a real hell would be unable to sleep knowing anyone was suffering there. However, people are able to sleep with all kinds of suffering happening everywhere.  Some people care more than others' of course, but there is  some coping mechanism that exists to tempoararily  help us  put such things out of minds or "ignore" it for lack of a better  word.    We'd all go nuts if we concentrated constantly on all the people who were suffering in this world, and I assume that also applies to thinking about those suffering in another realm (for those who beleive in one).


In my Christian days, I met many people who  (in my opinion)  truly beleived in Hell. My former step-father for example. He was a preacher who  could describe hell in Dante-like detail, and would literally break down crying while he preached or prayed about the topic. I don't think he was bullshitting, either, cause he was just as serious about it  behind closed doors.  His main goal in life was to convert people and save them from  a "Christless eternity"(his favorite phrase).   

If fundy  Christians really didn't beleive in hell, then I don't think they would have the cold streak that they do.   Even Christians who may be naturally decent, accepting people at heart are pretty much forced by the doctrine of God's eternal judgement to behave in harsh ways in certain situations. There's a fear there. A fear  for other people's souls, but more for their own. It's what makes them able to shun people, break off with their "unsaved" families, even (historically) to  committ violent acts or torture  The belief in hell is tied in with the belief in original sin, and I think that most fundies buy that story 100%.

snakechic
| Move to Top | Move to Bottom
 
7#



Rank:none
Status:
Score:0
Posts:3489
From:
Registered: 11/02/2004
Time spent: 1846 hours

RE:Would you still have served Christ without the fear of Hell?
(Date Posted:03/13/2008 20:05:36)

Reply to MissUnknown (03/12/2008 2:46 PM).
I have felt disgust with Christianity's God. I have also at the same time as you mentioned in another post used the same God as a crutch I guess.
I am in pretty bad health right now and it was always comforting for me to turn and pray and have that hope that if I just had enough faith that maybe I would be healed. To be honest this Christianity thing for me has been kind of a schizo experience.

(I'm not crazy but maybe I took things too literally) or that the bible really is that hard of a thing to live up to. I freaked out so bad at the thought of people burning in hell that I started warning and witnessing door to door and I looked like a religious freak to most people. There is a lot more to the story but it's long and I don't have the patience to write it all down now.
 
I do know that there are many out there risking their lives to witness to others and giving up most or if not all of what they have to serve Christ and I know that there are many more who don't.  For me that is not something I concern myself with most of the time of who's doing what.  Don't get me wrong it can be a disgusting thing to see what some so called christians do but my thoughts have always been there will always be those that abuse power or fake something for their own ends I can't be concerned with that to the point that it keeps me from seeking truth.

The problem with that article is that they lump all christians in the same boat. Just because the majority of Christians past or present have been deceitful or caused wars or whatever it is that they have done doesn't make all christians evil. ...  I'm not saying I'm not disgusted with a lot of Christianity the more I learn I'm just saying I'm not about to lump everyone in the same boat.
Hi..

I'm sorry you have current  ill health. I'll share something with you too. I'm waiting for tests to reveal if I have 'bad' stuff happening in my body but I'm not 'praying' or even contemplating 'a miracle'  - I take it as it comes and hope for the best results - if not I'll deal with it.
But...yeah I can see how  christianity would be a schizo experience.
And I think you're absolutely spot on...the bible is impossible to live with as a model or anything like that. It has so many contradictions, out of date social values - basically its a bunch of letters? I'm no expert but at the same time I'm so grateful I don't have a bunch of bible verses spinning around in my head.
Yeah..I know what you mean by not having patience - no one can possibly   write down everything that's going on or every single thought that is important to share and make sense of it all.
That's probably my 'bestest advice' (chuckles) is to take it slow and have some patience with yourself. It might feel like a race but really it isn't.

You mention a lot about 'seeking the truth'. What if you find out there is 'no truth'?. no One thing called 'truth'........only a bunch of possibilities or decisions for you to make. Or something else you come across that you like. ?

Yeah..the article does tend to generalise...but that's only one method to describe his thoughts on the matter and that's okay. I think its virtually impossible to NOT generalise to some degree and talk only about individuals -  we'd be  here all day.   I think its GREAT that you are not falling into that familiar 'black & white' distinction and can clearly see that the 'answers' are not so simple  as -   right and wrong.
I think on the subject of 'hell' and punishment...and of course the judgements that come with that - that christians (generally) take huge liberties and use that 'fear' against each other and of course 'non believers' alike.
For example....I don't believe in 'hell' but that does NOT exclude me from being judged and condemned by those who do   - I am immediately 'doomed to hell' ..for nothing - for not believing. That's not fair...not to mention that it makes my existence in the world a huge value to christians who NEED to 'prove' their faith etc. and use me as some kind of object for evangelising. That to me is not 'fair' use.
I guess there are all kinds of different perspectives to consider in this ....including the one I just mentioned - that christians d